How To Self-Assess SEO Content, According to Google
  • 13-minute read
  • 10th December 2024

How To Self-Assess SEO Content, According to Google

It’s important to know how to self-assess SEO content, and Google’s guidelines for SEO can’t be ignored. Creating content that ranks well in search engine results pages (SERPs) and serves your audience’s needs has become more crucial than ever. 

Google’s Helpful Content Guidelines have set a clear direction – content should be created for people first, not search engines. This recent emphasis has transformed how SEO and content creation should be approached. Keyword stuffing and thin content can no longer achieve high rankings. Today’s successful content strategy requires a delicate balance between SEO best practices and creating genuine value for your audience.

This comprehensive checklist will help you navigate Google’s guidelines while providing actionable strategies to create content that not only ranks well but also builds trust with your audience. You’ll learn how to align your content with the guidelines while maintaining strong SEO practices, which will ultimately lead to better search visibility and increased user engagement.

Keep reading to discover a method for self-assessing your past, present, and future content to ensure it doesn’t disappear into the search engine void.

Understanding Google's Helpful Content Guidelines

For successful SEO content, you need to know what makes good content according to Google, and its Helpful Content Guidelines represent a fundamental shift in how search engines evaluate content quality. At their core, these guidelines emphasize the crucial principle stated above: content should be created primarily for people, not search engines.

Let’s look at the two aspects of this principle.

Focus on User-First Content

User-first content is created for people to enjoy and learn from. It should demonstrate several key characteristics:

  • Show clear expertise and first-hand knowledge of the topic
  • Provide comprehensive answers to user queries
  • Offer unique insights beyond surface-level information
  • Deliver a satisfying experience that meets the reader’s needs

Avoid Search Engine-First Content

Google explicitly warns against content that’s created primarily for ranking purposes. Red flags include:

  • Mass-produced content covering multiple topics without genuine expertise
  • Content that merely summarizes other sources without adding value
  • Following arbitrary word counts or formatting rules based on perceived SEO benefits
  • Creating content solely because topics are trending, without real audience value

To make sure your content aligns with these two aspects and follows the main principle, we have developed a 15-step, easy-to-follow checklist broken into five phases:

  1. Pre-writing
  2. Writing
  3. Post-writing
  4. Quality assurance
  5. Updates and enhancements

Phase 1: Pre-Writing

Before you start creating content, you should establish a few key details. This sets you up to create SEO content that puts people first and serves a genuine purpose.

1. Define Your Audience

This is one of the most crucial stages for audience-first SEO. You need to identify who you’re creating content for and why they would want to view it. Consider your existing or intended audience’s specific needs and what problems they might be trying to solve. Think of their level of expertise in the topic or niche and keep common questions and pain points in mind.

Here are some methods for learning more about your audience:

  • Create detailed reader personas.
    • Use Google Analytics demographic data.
    • Review insights from your social media followers.
    • Analyze your email subscribers’ demographics.
  • Survey existing or potential customers.
    • What’s their primary challenge with [topic]?
    • Where do they typically look for information?
    • What’s their experience level with [topic]?
    • What format do they prefer for learning?
  • Understand search intent by using Google Search Console.
    • What are the most common search queries leading to your site?
    • Which pages have the highest and lowest click-through rates (CTRs)?
    • Consider mobile vs. desktop user preferences.
  • Create a marketing matrix of search intent.
    Make sure it includes:

    • Informational queries
    • Navigational queries
    • Commercial queries
    • Transactional queries
  • Analyze for gaps in content.
    Compare existing material with queries from:

    • Support tickets
    • Sales calls
    • Social media comments
    • Forum discussions
  • Try to fill any gaps.
    Prioritize based on:

    • Search volume
    • Competition level
    • Business impact
    • Resource requirements

2. Keyword Research

Setting keywords for SEO success is important, and that starts with research. Approach keyword research strategically by focusing on search intent rather than just search volume. Look for long-tail keywords that indicate specific user needs and group related keywords to create comprehensive content.

You can use some of the following tools for your initial keyword discovery:

Here’s how to perform keyword research:

  • Find the best keywords.
    • Start with seed keywords.
    • Export all terms related to your niche.
    • Group by search intent.
    • Filter by volume and difficulty.
    • Prioritize based on your business goals.
  • Analyze keywords from your competitors.
    • Find out what makes successful content stand out.
    • Identify areas where existing content falls short.
    • Look for opportunities to provide unique perspectives.
    • Study content structure and depth of coverage.
    • Export ranking keywords from top competitors.
    • Analyze featured snippet opportunities.
    • Track keyword difficulty scores.
  • Create topic clusters to help keep your keywords organized.
    • Identify pillar content topics.
    • List related subtopics.
    • Map keywords to your different content types.
    • Create an internal linking plan.
    • Set up tracking for each cluster.

3. Writing Process Implementation

Now that you’ve researched your audience and keywords, it’s time to brainstorm and plan the actual content. Here are four tools and services to ensure your creation process is as smooth as possible:

Google emphasizes the importance of originality and value addition, so make sure you have a plan before writing.

  • Well-structured, informative, and factually correct content is the most valuable.
    • Create a detailed outline.
    • Research statistics and sources.
    • Identify subject matter experts.
    • Plan multimedia elements.
    • Set up tracking parameters.

Phase 2: Writing

By this point, you should have all the information you need to get started, so it’s time to get creative.

4. Create Original and Valuable Content

Wordsmith your content for SEO while creating something that will be beneficial to your audience and demonstrate your expertise.

  • Offer insights beyond the obvious.
    • Personalize your content to the reader.
    • Draw from first-hand experience or genuine expertise.
    • Include original research or data when possible.
    • Provide practical examples and case studies.
    • Offer actionable advice based on real experience.
  • Perform a quick self-assessment.
    Before publishing, ask yourself:

    • Does this content demonstrate genuine expertise?
    • Would readers bookmark or share this information?
    • Does it provide more value than existing search results?
    • Is the content comprehensive enough to satisfy user intent?
    • Am I providing unique insights or perspectives?

5. Structure for Readability

Make sure your content is structured so it’s easy to consume. You don’t want people to ignore what you’ve created just because it looks bad.

  • Well-structured content helps readers find and understand information quickly.
    • Use clear, descriptive headings and subheadings.
    • Break up long paragraphs.
    • Include bullet points for key takeaways.
    • Use white space effectively.
    • Ensure a logical flow of information.

6. Avoid Factual Errors

Nothing turns a reader off faster than reading something filled with errors. Building trust is crucial for long-term success.

  • Maintain accuracy and credibility at all times.
    • Verify all facts and statistics.
    • Create links to authoritative sources.
    • Update content regularly to ensure accuracy.
    • Include dates for time-sensitive information.

Phase 3: Post-Writing

Although the writing is finished, the work isn’t done. It’s time to polish and make your content into an SEO masterpiece.

7. Enhance Content

To make your content creation process easier, you can take certain steps:

  • Don’t neglect technical optimization.
  • Ensure consistency in your ongoing content structure.
    • Create custom content templates.
    • Set up automated formatting.
    • Configure image optimization.
    • Set up internal linking rules.
  • Develop a quality control process.
    It should include:

    • Technical proofreading checklist
    • Fact-checking protocol
    • Source verification system
    • Expert review process
    • User feedback collection
  • Consider adding multimedia elements.
    Master the art of visual storytelling by:

    • Including relevant images
    • Adding informative videos when appropriate
    • Creating helpful infographics
    • Including data visualizations
    • Optimizing all media files
  • Implement engagement features.
    • Add a table of contents for long content.
    • Include jump links to sections.
    • Create content upgrades.
    • Add social sharing buttons.
    • Include related content suggestions.

8. Optimize for On-Page SEO

SEO writing and organization will boost your rankings in SERPs. After you have finished creating your content, take some time to optimize and make sure the technical SEO elements have been implemented carefully.

  • Ensure everything about your content is streamlined for SEO.

9. User Experience (UX) Focus

It’s crucial that your content is easy and enjoyable to access.

  • Emphasize the importance of overall user experience.
    • Test loading speeds across devices.
    • Optimize for mobile viewing.
    • Minimize intrusive advertisements.
    • Ensure easy navigation.
    • Check for broken links.

10. Engagement and Conversion Optimization

Beyond being enjoyable, it’s important for your content to encourage user interaction.

  • Foster conversion through user engagement.
    • Include relevant calls-to-action.
    • Add interactive elements where appropriate.
    • Enable comments and discussion.
    • Provide sharing options.
    • Include relevant internal links.

Phase 4: Quality Assurance and Regular Audits

Once you’re consistently producing quality SEO content, you’ll want to occasionally check over everything to make sure it’s still as effective as it needs to be.

11. Content Review

Take a good look at your content and search for any areas that can be improved.

12. SEO Final Check

Whether your goal is local SEO or more far reaching, check over everything one more time to ensure you have the best content.

  • Verify your SEO elements.
    • Check keyword placement.
    • Review meta descriptions.
    • Verify title tags.
    • Confirm heading structure.
    • Test internal links.
  • Validate technical aspects.
    • Test page speed.
    • Check mobile responsiveness.
    • Verify schema markup.
    • Confirm indexability.
    • Check Core Web Vitals.

Phase 5: Updates and Enhancements

For peak SEO, you need to regularly put out new content and update your existing material. It’s also possible to repurpose content for new audiences.

13. Regular Content Updates

First, check your existing content and see if there’s anything you can do to make it better.

14. Ongoing Improvements

After reviewing and checking performance metrics, you’ll have a better idea of how you can improve your future SEO content.

  • Implement improvements based on data.
    • Update underperforming sections.
    • Add missing information.
    • Enhance weak areas.
    • Improve UX.
    • Optimize for featured snippets.
  • Stay current with guidelines.
    • Monitor Google’s helpful content guidelines updates.
    • Review new SEO best practices.
    • Update according to algorithm changes.
    • Implement new content features.
    • Adapt to changing user needs.

Having the Best SEO Content All the Time

This comprehensive checklist ensures your content meets both user needs and search engine requirements while maintaining high-quality standards. Regular review and updates of your content using this checklist will help maintain its effectiveness and relevance over time.

Remember that following Google’s helpful content guidelines, its E-E-A-T criteria, and implementing proper SEO best practices is an ongoing process that requires consistent attention and updates. Think of this checklist as a living document – update it as new guidelines and best practices emerge.

By using this checklist and staying updated, you’ll be well positioned to create content that performs well in SERPs while providing genuine value to your audience. But don’t let your content slip in quality. If you want to ensure that all your words make an impact, Proofed’s advertising and marketing department is here to help. Our specialized proofreading services will not only make all of your marketing material flawless, but we’ll tailor it to your target audience or industry. Schedule a call with us to see how our experts can help. 

FAQs

1. What are the key components of Google's Helpful Content Guidelines?

The guidelines center around four fundamental principles:

  1. User-first content creation
  2. Content relevance
  3. Originality
  4. Trustworthiness

These principles emphasize creating content that demonstrates genuine expertise, serves a clear purpose, and provides substantial value beyond what’s already available. Key components include focusing on your site’s primary purpose, demonstrating first-hand knowledge, and ensuring content comprehensively addresses user needs rather than just targeting search engines.

2. How often should SEO content be self-assessed?

The frequency of content assessment should align with your industry’s pace of change and content type. For rapidly evolving industries like technology or news, monthly assessments may be necessary. For more stable industries, quarterly reviews might suffice. However, certain triggers should prompt immediate assessment:

    • Significant changes in search rankings
    • Major industry developments
    • Updates to Google’s algorithms
    • Notable changes in user engagement metrics 

Regularly monitoring key performance indicators can help you identify when deeper assessments are needed.

3. What's the best way to measure user engagement with content?

Effective measurement of user engagement involves analyzing multiple metrics. The most important ones are listed in #14 of our checklist (including bounce and conversion rates), but there are other valuable metrics to track:

    • Time on page: Look for patterns that indicate thorough content consumption.
    • CTR: Compare this against industry benchmarks.
    • Scroll depth: Identify where users typically stop reading.
    • User interactions: Quantify comments, shares, and return visits.

The key is focusing on metrics that align with your content goals rather than tracking everything possible.

4. How does Google's E-E-A-T impact SEO performance?

E-E-A-T significantly influences how Google evaluates content quality. While the criteria itself isn’t a direct ranking factor, it serves as a framework for multiple ranking signals.

Strong E-E-A-T can improve SEO performance by building user trust, encouraging return visits, and attracting natural backlinks from authoritative sources. Following the criteria can reduce bounce rates through credible content and increase content sharing and engagement. This is especially crucial for Your Money or Your Life topics, where Google holds content to higher standards.

5. Why is comparing against competitor content important?

Competitor analysis serves multiple strategic purposes beyond simple benchmarking:

    • Identifies content gaps in your market
    • Reveals successful content formats and approaches
    • Helps set appropriate content depth and scope
    • Highlights opportunities for differentiation
    • Provides insights into evolving user needs 

However, the goal isn’t to copy competitors but to understand market standards and find ways to provide unique value that better serves your audience’s needs.

  • Jump to Section

Want to bite down on your content crunch?

Want to bite down on your content crunch?

Our professional SEO-trained editors have you covered.

Looking For
The Perfect Partner?

Let’s talk about the support you need.